Questions You Answer in Each Peer Review
General Comments to the Student about the Analysis: What was good about the Analysis and what can be improved?
Free Response
Minimum answer length: 25
Did the student follow Good Habit 1: Reliable Sources Only? If some sentences contain facts that are not from the textbook or from one of the primary sources provided, identify each of these sentences by typing the endnote # or #s. Also briefly say the problem.
Free Response
Minimum answer length: 10
Did the student follow Good Habit 2: Factual Accuracy That You Verify with the Reliable Source Before You Write? If the student did such things as assumed, misread, cherry-picked, or embellished, identify where in the paper by typing the endnote # or #s. Also briefly say the problem.
Free Response
Minimum answer length: 10
Did the student follow Good Habit 3: Factual Accuracy That Is Verifiable for Every Statement You Make? If the student did not cite a fact or cited a page but that page did not support what the student said, identify what fact(s) were incorrectly cited by writing the endnote # or #s. Also briefly say the problem.
Free Response
Minimum answer length: 10
Did the student follow Good Habit 4: No “Half-Copy” Plagiarism or “Patchwriting”? Write the endnote # or #s for each sentence where the student did either of these things: a) if the student copied words from the textbook or the primary but did not put pairs (“”) of quotation marks around those borrowed words or b) if the student copied the sentence structure of the source and just swapped out a few words with what he or she thought were synonyms. Also briefly say the problem.
Free Response
Minimum answer length: 10
Did the student follow Good Habit 5: Quotation Changes Revealed Clearly? Write the endnote # or #s for each sentence where the student has pairs of quotation marks (“”) around words but the author did not write those exact words. Also briefly say the problem.
Free Response
Minimum answer length: 10
With this one, I have placed a), b) through e) on separate lines.
Copy what is the most appropriate description for this Analysis and write briefly why the description is the most appropriate one: 
a) Serious factual errors, including in the source; 
b) Serious general errors; 
c) Factually accurate and consisting of two summaries but without analysis; 
d) Factually accurate and showing analysis but not synthesis of interconnections, or 
e) Factually accurate and showing analysis, synthesis of interconnections, and clear and representative examples.
Free Response
Minimum answer length: 25

Minimum answer length: 2